7 Dumb Ways to Feed Your Lawn

March 2, 2012 | By | Comments (12)

Lawns 008 copy
Now that homeowners across the South are just about finished butchering their crepe myrtles for the year, they’re turning their attention to another dumb thing they shouldn’t do — fertilizing their grass at the wrong time.

Grumpy realizes that many vocal lawn-haters out there don’t want you to fertilize ever, because you shouldn’t have a lawn ever. To them I say, it’s your yard and this is America — do what you want. Plant a wilderness. Fill a swamp. Artistically arrange rocks.

But this doesn’t help the millions of decent, law-abiding lawn-lovers who need to and want to fertilize correctly. So here’s Grumpy’s list of lawn fertilizing DON’TS for early spring.

Fert 003Look for phosphorus-free lawn fertilizer this spring. It cuts down on water pollution. 


DON’T apply fertilizer that’s high in phosphorus. Phosphorus washing into lakes and rivers can result in the explosive growth of algae. As algae die, a process called eutrophication robs the water of oxygen and kills fish. Besides, most lawns already have all the phosphorus they need. To find how much phosphorus a bag of fertilizer contains, look for the middle number in the three-number analysis on the label. A bag of 18-24-10 contains 24% phosphorus. Many major fertilizer companies, such as Scott’s, have committed to totally eliminating phosphorus (P) from all lawn fertilizers by the end of this year. Good.

Fert 001Triple-13 fertilizer is cheapo crapola that should not be used on lawns.

DON’T use cheap, quick-release fertilizers like 13-13-13. Sure, it costs about half of the brand names, but its nutrients run off after a heavy rain and don’t feed for long. Brand names contain more slow-release nitrogen, the most important nutrient for lawns, so they feed longer and pollute less. And 13-13-13 contains 13% phosphorus, a nutrient we promised we weren’t going to apply anymore, remember?

DON’T fertilize dormant grass. Grass uses nitrogen for making grass blades, but if it’s not growing yet, you’re wasting your money and also adding to groundwater pollution. In the South, where we grow warm-weather grass, it’s easy to tell when the lawn is dormant. It’s brown. Wait until it greens up. Farther north where grass stays green in winter, it’s a bit trickier. Wait to fertilize until after the ground thaws or you see spring trees and shrubs blooming.

DON’T use fertilizer to melt snow and ice on sidewalks. Snow melt will carry nitrogen from the fertilizer into groundwater and storm drains.

DON’T get fertilizer on sidewalks, driveways, and other pavement. Rain will quickly wash it into the gutter, storm drains, and water bodies. Sweep any stray fertilizer back into the grass. Healthy lawns do a very good job of holding onto fertilizer particles, even during heavy rain.

DON’T fertilize more often than necessary. For warm-season grasses, fertilize once in spring and once in summer. For cool-season grasses, fertilize once in spring and once in fall. And use a mulching mower to return clippings to the lawn. Not only does this keep lawn clippings out of landfills, but it also reduces the need for fertilizer and improves the soil’s biological activity.

DON’T use weed-and-feed in early spring. It only works on actively growing weeds (and even then, not too well). Apply it too early and all you’ll do is feed the weeds.

Phunny Phosphorus Story!!!!

Think about it. What other blog could you read that offers you a humorous anecdote about phosphorus? That’s why “The Grumpy Gardener” remains the World’s #1 Blog, as tabulated in a formal poll conducted last week by Grumpy himself.

The story: Many years ago, former Southern Living Garden Editor Lois Chaplin was writing an article about ways to improve your soil and give it the right balance of plant nutrients. One of those nutrients is phosphorus, which we gardening cognoscenti shorten to “P.” When Lois began a sentence, “If your soil has too much P,” our copy editor, Louise, nearly had a stroke. Louise was terrified that readers might infer that heathens were relieving themselves in the garden.

Just so you know — no one connected to Southern Living has ever relieved themselves anywhere. We hold it from birth until we explode.





  1. Rob

    Interesting to note that we had our soil tested and found it to be severely depleted in phosphorous and they recommended using a 10-10-10 or even a 15-15-15 AFTER using a 28-0-3 fertilizer in the spring….based on what you have indicated I should not use Phosphorous….Hmmmmm…now what?…any recommendations?….Our lawn is green and weed free, but very thin since the phosphorous is for root growth. and ours is very weak.

    April 14, 2017 at 7:56 pm
  2. Teresa

    How do I kill sand spurs in my combo st. Augustine and Bermuda yard in crystal Beach TX.on Bolivar peninsula. Texas.

    December 10, 2016 at 3:13 am
  3. benefits of wheatgrass

    Your site articles and posts are very useful, I am very much interested with you. Thanks for sharing such a good and helpful posts. You mentioned that information was very nice to us. Thank you

    August 5, 2016 at 4:15 am
  4. Rick Neisen

    Thanks for sharing 7 Dumb Ways to Feed Your Lawn.I have my own business in which I provide Commercial Lawn Care, Residential Lawn Care, Professional Lawn Care and much more in Anoka, Andover, Coon Rapids, Blaine, Fridley, Champlain. I offer two great lawn care packages to keep your lawn looking green and healthy all season. When you sign up with one of RICKS lawn care packages, you will receive our expertise and our healthy lawn analysis. We customize your lawn care package to fit your lawn so that it remains healthy all season. To know more about us: – http://www.rickslawnandsnow.com/#!lawn-care-fertilizer/csqg

    May 10, 2016 at 4:35 am
  5. Anne Fischer

    I am in Michigan and just bought a big bag of Scott’s weed and feed!!!! When should I apply? You say not early spring….so does that mean to wait til August….that’s when weeds are most active!?

    March 20, 2016 at 2:17 pm
  6. Grumpy Gardener (His Magnificence)

    Do the opposite of the dont’s.

    March 20, 2012 at 12:39 pm
  7. Donna

    I hear all the donts but what’s the do’s.?

    March 19, 2012 at 11:23 am
  8. Grumpy Gardener (His Magnificence)

    What is his problem, Ursula?
    As far as poisoning bees, I don’t like that either, but I have no evidence that reasonable lawn care does that. If you’re really concerned, just skip applying any lawn insecticides. Herbicides applied to the surface shouldn’t affect them.

    March 9, 2012 at 12:02 pm
  9. C_Shank

    I am having an inner battle with fertilizing my lawn. I attended a rather informative workshop about bees and found that many of them burrow in the soil and also lay their larvae there…meaning, anything we apply to the soil – pesticide or fertilizer – directly affects their health. Do I want a patchy, weedy lawn? Not really. But can I live with the idea that I’m poisoning the bees? Ugh, no.

    March 6, 2012 at 4:49 pm
  10. UrsulaV

    Y’know, my ex-husband always balked at…err…marking the edges of the garden to keep deer out. Never met a man so stingy with his bodily fluids. Sheesh.

    March 6, 2012 at 11:42 am
  11. Richared S. George

    Does Lois Chaplin habla español? The verb PISAR in Spanish means walk on, like “no pisar la cesped” which means “do not walk on the grass”

    March 2, 2012 at 5:15 pm
  12. B-J Ellis, HollyCroft Farm, VA

    I’m a NewEnglnader and I lOVE your sarasm, but it DOES make the point. Since there are so many small farmers in Marylend, PA, VA, AL, Can you advize the difference between fertilizing for livestock fields, versus the quarte-acre here? Thanks I send people to your site all the time in my articles about alpacas. Get it? Thanks; Now I’l send more.

    March 2, 2012 at 4:27 pm

Leave a Comment

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s