“Idol” or “Deadliest Catch”? Cast Your Vote!

May 13, 2008 | By | Comments (5)

Fellow Grumpians, I have to confess a weakness, shocking as it may be.

For tonight, what’s happening on TV is a lot more compelling than what’s happening in my garden.

For years, I’d been an “American Idol” addict. Saw Reuben crowned, saw Daughtry totally ripped off, saw Carrie prove that she’s more wholesome than mac & cheese served in a convent.

What Were They Thinking?But then those evil puppet masters of network programming did the unspeakable. They scheduled “Idol” to appear on Tuesday night opposite Discovery’s “The Deadliest Catch.”

This is like telling me I have a choice of one food to eat for the rest of my life – Death by Chocolate ice cream or a big, juicy, medium-rare, Black Angus ribeye. No human should have to make such a choice.

Smell the Testosterone
Now, some ladies out there may be unfamiliar with “The Deadliest Catch.” It is a man’s show, after all, which is why the Grump looks forward to it each week with the fervor of a starving pet goldfish awaiting his food pellets. As narrator Mike Rowe solemnly intones each week in his manly, masculine baritone voice, TDC is a reality show centered on, “The vast Bering Sea. Over a million square miles of the most violent and unpredictable waters on Earth. And home to the deadliest catch – Alaskan crab.” At this moment, if you stick your nose up to the TV, you can smell testosterone oozing right through the screen.

The Four Norsemen
The show chronicles the exploits of four crab boats and four captains – Sig Hansen, Phil Harris, Johnathan Hillstrand, and Keith Colburn – as they tackle monstrous waves and freezing water to catch highly lucrative Alaskan king crab. I actually worry about these guys. When Phil’s crab pots all came up empty last week, I though I might cry. Still, there’s no way I’d want to be in their shoes. Everyone on the boat is always cold and wet, they work 36 hours at a time, they smoke Camels faster than Camel can make them, and drink Red Bull like it’s mother’s milk. Worst of all, the way I figure it, each boat has only one toilet.

On the Horns of a Dilemma
What show should I watch this week? I used to watch “Deadliest Catch” and turn to “Idol” during the commercials. That way, I could get a sense of what was going on while missing most of Paula’s mindless babbling. But it’s crunch-time on “Idol” now. That talentless Sideshow Bob lookalike Jason Castro got voted off last week for butchering “Mr. Tambourine Man” (Honestly, how hard is it to remember “in the jingle-jangle morning, I’ll come following you?” It’s not like we asked him to sing, “The Star Spangled Banner.”)

So we’re down to three contestants – David Cook (the most talented), David Archuleta (so incredibly cute, nice, and wholesome he makes Carrie Underwood seem evil incarnate by comparison), and Syesha Mercado, who will get voted off tomorrow night. Which of the Davids will choke? The tension is unbearable.

On the other hand, will Captain Sig sink? Will Captain Phil’s mercurial blood pressure create an aneurysm as big as a cod? Will Captain Johnathan rise above the pressure and remember all the words to “Mr. Tambourine Man?”

Grumpians, the decision rests with you. Which show should I watch?


  1. Grumpy

    A female fan of “Deadliest Catch!” Be still my beating heart! So who’s your favorite guy on the show? Are you naturally attracted to men who smell like cod?
    You probably won’t get around to answering this today, because you’ll be glued to the TV set all day, as Discovery is running a 48-hour “Deadliest Catch” marathon covering all the seasons so far. I plan to watch tonight eating a big, juicy hunk of ribeye and washing it down with a nice shiraz. Then I’m going to bite the head off of a herring.

    May 26, 2008 at 8:38 am
  2. mss @ Zanthan Gardens

    If you go to the Idol site, you can watch clips of all the performances (choose your performer) and a summary of what the judges have to say. No commercials, no Ryan Seacrist, and no filler.
    BTW, I love watcing the Deadliest Catch and I’m all estrogen.

    May 25, 2008 at 4:15 pm
  3. grumpygardener

    Was I right or was I right? The contest is now down to the two Davids. I like David Cook better, because I’m not a 12-year old girl, but the contest can go either way. What will ultimately make the difference is which one of the two is given the worse songs to sing by the producers. Please don’t make them sing any inane, forgettable, elevator music by Diane Warren! She is Ambien in human form.
    Regarding “Deadliest Catch,” I am very troubled. Captain Phil Harris was absent from the whole episode and there was a hint at the end he might not be back. How can they toy with my emotions this way?

    May 15, 2008 at 3:34 pm
  4. pat

    ummm…I can spell, can’t type though!….And I hope for David Cook!

    May 14, 2008 at 4:47 pm
  5. pat

    Well …Deadliest catch repeats 2 hours later…so you can watch both…Also try Alaskan Experience on DSC channel, at 9p.m. It is reall ygood. Its about 4 groups of people dropped off in the Alaskan Wilderness, to try to survive a winter. Then aftyer that Deadliest is run again!!

    May 14, 2008 at 4:46 pm

Leave a Comment

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s