Are Monarch Butterflies Doomed?

April 3, 2016 | By | Comments (7)
Monarch butterfly


More than three million species of insects exist in the world and people hate just about all of them. We therefore take note when one particular insect, the monarch butterfly, earns universal love and widespread concern. Monarch populations are noticeably declining, so we have to ask: If things keep going the way they are, could monarchs go extinct?

Insects multiply so fast and in such large numbers that it’s hard to imagine any could totally disappear from the Earth. But it’s happened before. According to Endangered Species International, 59 insect species have vanished in modern times — including the lovely  Xerces blue butterfly after San Francisco developers destroyed its coastal sand dune habitat.

Fortunately, the monarch lives over a much larger area than the Xerces. It stretches from Canada to Mexico. But like the Xerces, it suffers from the potentially fatal flaw of overspecialization. It eats only one kind of plant. And much of the total population — an estimated one billion monarchs — spend the entire winter in a very small area of the Sierra Madre Mountains in central Mexico.

Be afraid. Be very afraid.

Although adult monarchs drink nectar from many kinds of flowers, their caterpillars eat only the foliage of milkweeds, such as common milkweed (Asclepias syriaca), butterfly weed (Asclepias tuberosa), and swamp milkweed (Asclepias incarnata). There used to be plenty of milkweeds around — you don’t get called a “weed” for nothing. However, much milkweed habitat — fields, grasslands, roadsides — is lost to development each year. In the Midwest, large swaths of marginal cropland that formerly supported milkweeds have been plowed under and planted with corn to make ethanol — a short-sighted gift from Congress to the deep-pocket lobbies of Big Ag.

Common milkweed

Common milkweed in the wild. Photo:

Or should I say, Big Gag. Fewer milkweeds = fewer monarchs. But we have ethanol!

The Really Big Threat
However, a more existential threat to monarchs is their amazing mass migration from Canada and the U.S. to the trees of a 200 square-mile area in Mexico called the Monarch Butterfly Biosphere Reserve. Here the monarchs wait out the cold winter up north by roosting in the trees in such mind-boggling multitudes that branches sometimes break and  fall under their weight. When instinct tells them it’s time to leave, they mate and start the thousand-mile journey home, laying eggs on milkweeds along the way.

But what if something terrible happens while they’re still so concentrated in the Reserve? Logging takes place in parts of it. In 2002, a freak winter storm killed 70% of the overwintering butterflies, leaving piles of dead monarchs two feet deep on the forest floor. What if the next storm is more severe? What if some delusional maniac with a helicopter and tank of DDT decides to sterilize the Reserve to get his 15 minutes of fame? Harvey Updyke Jr. pulled the same kind of stunt when he poisoned Toomer’s Oaks at Auburn University.

Be afraid. Be very afraid.

What Can Be Done?
Thanks to their migratory imperatives, monarchs will always be at risk no matter what we do. We can’t stop a storm. However, we can do things close to home to mitigate the risk and make us feel better. We can stop turning farms into shopping malls. We can stop converting marginal cropland into ethanol factories.

Many monarch advocates urge everyone to plant common milkweed in their gardens to replace what’s lost in the wild. This is problematical. For one thing, Joe Sixpack hasn’t heard of common milkweed, wouldn’t know common milkweed if it kicked him in the chiclets, and no garden center in town sells it. And let’s be honest — it’s an invasive weed that spreads quickly by seeds and rhizomes. That’s fine for people who live on farms or have an acre or two to devote to native plants. But in the burbs? No way. It’s just not the next ‘Endless Summer.’

What now? How about planting a nice milkweed with spectacular flowers that Joe Sixpack will love? Butterfly weed.

Butterfly weed

Butterfly weed. Photo: Ladybird Johnson Wildflower Center

Butterfly weed is native, perennial, well-behaved, tough-as-nails, and easy to grow. It forms a clump about three feet tall and crowns itself in early summer with blossoms that are usually bright orange, but may be red or yellow. All it needs is sun and well-drained soil. Due to long tap roots, it’s difficult to dig from the wild. However, it’s easy to grow from seed and you can get plants at many garden centers and mail-order nurseries. Adult butterflies (many kinds, not just monarchs) love its nectar. Monarch caterpillars munch on its foliage. Here’s what a happy monarch caterpillar looks like.

Monarch caterpillar

Monarch butterfly caterpillar. Photo:

Of course, if you really want your garden to be one of millions of tiny refuges that keep monarchs going, you’ll have to back off pesticides. You don’t want to be a less-famous version of the maniac in the helicopter.








  1. Jamie

    Actually this is incorrect. “Big Ag” – specifically Monsanto – is doing quite a bit to restore the Monarch population.

    May 23, 2016 at 11:08 am
  2. Rebecca

    I’d be interested in hearing a further explanation of the author’s “Big Ag or should I say Big Gag” comment. Could you share with us some further detail?

    April 9, 2016 at 5:47 pm
  3. peggy

    Another butterfly that needs help is the black swallowtail. The caterpillar is almost identical to the monarch. It’s host plant (feeder) is parsley, will also eat carrot tops. plant parsley with miikweed . Seeds are harder to grow. If you buy plants, get organic pesticide free, or wash plants with veggie wash a few times. I used to have swallowtails but none for 2 years. Ask your local garden store to save plants with caterpillars on them for you, you will probably have to pay full price, but it is worth it. The nursery brand I found with caterpillars on them i called Simply Beautiful . spread the word, because unlike milkweed , humans eat parsley and compete for it, and kill the caterpillars that they consider pests. Google Black Swallow tail for more info and see if they are native to your area.

    April 7, 2016 at 6:33 pm
  4. Jeannette

    I agree with Sue. I was surprised to see your article encouraging using pesticides to rid the garden of yellow and black caterpillars. Would have been nice to see you explain what these caterpillars become and what we can do to help keep them around. Some people don’t know what some bugs become. And most people don’t understand that certain plants are devoured but will come back. That is the cycle of the butterflies life.

    April 6, 2016 at 3:28 pm
  5. Sue

    I’m concerned that the reply to “Caterpillar Killers” in this month’s column will contribute to this decline. Monarch caterpillars could reasonably be classified as “black-and-yellow” (and white) and you recommend to kill on sight!

    April 5, 2016 at 3:11 pm
  6. Annie

    Peyton, I currently grow butterfly weed and swamp milkweed in containers on my apartment porch and the plants do well. I’ve never attracted monarchs, but last year I had so many gulf fritillaries on another host plant (passion vine) that they ate it to the ground!

    April 4, 2016 at 12:09 pm
  7. Peyton

    We live in an apartment and are looking to use containers to plant around our house. I am going to investigate this milkweed. It is a shame that these articles are starting to get these internet scammers.

    April 3, 2016 at 2:38 pm

Leave a Comment

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s